Top-Rated Shower Replacement Pros in Brookhaven, NY
This site usually splits shower replacement pros into tile, plumbing and glass; Brookhaven doesn't have the license data to do that yet, so this page works from Google instead. The 10 businesses below sit in one ranked list rather than our usual trade split, ordered by combining their star rating with review count. A high rating tells you what past customers thought, nothing about which license, if any, a business holds.
Google Maps ratings checked · How we rank
74%of homes built before 1980
What Brookhaven's housing stock means for shower replacement
The typical home in Brookhaven was built around 1967.
About 74% of Brookhaven's housing units were built before 1980, old enough that an original shower has very likely been replaced at least once already.
So a Brookhaven shower replacement often means removing a prior replacement, not the home's original fixtures.
Google's top-rated shower replacement businesses for Brookhaven, NY
One ranked list here instead of the usual tile, plumbing and glass split, ordered by a score that combines star rating and review count. That combined score says nothing about licensing, so ask any business which license, if any, covers its part of the job.
Preferred Remodeling & Construction Co.
Contractor
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 93
- Area
- Not listed
Accessible Remodeling
Bathroom remodeler
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 61
- Area
- Oakdale 11769
Elevated Construction, LI
Construction company
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 30
- Area
- Not listed
Quality
Roofing contractor
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 25
- Area
- Shirley 11967
Benitez Remodeling
General contractor
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 28
- Area
- Not listed
JBL Home Improvements
Remodeler
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 15
- Area
- Not listed
Stoneworks home improvement
Contractor
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 11
- Area
- Not listed
Patera Contracting
Construction company
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 10
- Area
- Shirley 11967
Fix it Right Remodeling & Home Maintenance LLC
Remodeler
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 7
- Area
- Bellport 11713
TBM Contractor LLC
Contractor
- Google rating
- Reviews
- 6
- Area
- Not listed
Questions for each trade
- Tile: who waterproofs the wall before new tile goes up, and what product do they use?
- Tile: does the quote include removing the old surround, or does that happen separately?
- Plumbing: is the new valve pressure-balance or thermostatic, and what brand and model?
- Plumbing: does the drain stay in its current spot, or is it moving?
- Glass: framed or frameless, and is the glass tempered to meet the safety-glazing rule for wet locations?
- Glass: what's the lead time on ordering, since custom glass is often the longest-lead item on the job?
- All trades: who is the single point of contact if something needs to be redone?